Washington Crossing Pipeline Leak: What Upper Makefield Well Owners, Buyers and Sellers Need to Know

November 20, 2026

If you live in Washington Crossing or anywhere in Upper Makefield, you've heard about the Sunoco pipeline leak in Mt. Eyre Manor. Nearly two years in, there still isn't an approved cleanup plan. On Tuesday, December 8, DEP is holding an in-person community meeting about where things stand. I think every homeowner on a private well in this part of Upper Makefield should be there, and so should anyone thinking about buying here.

Here's what happened, what's being done, and what I'd tell my own buyers and sellers.

What happened in Mt. Eyre Manor

The leak came from Sunoco Pipeline L.P.'s Twin Oaks–Newark pipeline, a 14-inch line owned by Energy Transfer that runs under the Mt. Eyre Manor neighborhood. On January 31, 2025, Energy Transfer confirmed the pipeline had leaked petroleum and contaminated seven residential wells, according to DEP. Neighbors had been noticing petroleum odors before that. DEP's records show staff checking odors on Glenwood Drive and Walker Road as early as January 9, 2025.

Sunoco's remedial action plan identifies the product as Jet A fuel. DEP lists jet fuel, diesel and gasoline as the possible fuels.

The timeline so far

  • Jan. 31, 2025: Leak confirmed; seven wells contaminated.
  • Feb. 13, 2025: Sunoco files its notice of intent to clean up under Pennsylvania's Act 2 to the residential statewide health standard. The federal pipeline regulator (PHMSA) proposes a safety order requiring lower operating pressure on the line.
  • Mar. 6, 2025: DEP orders Energy Transfer to keep supplying bottled water, sample and maintain home treatment systems, and submit a long-term cleanup plan.
  • Apr. 22, 2026: DEP approves Sunoco's interim site characterization report.
  • Jun. 19, 2026: Sunoco submits its remedial action plan, which proposes testing multiphase extraction (MPE) to pull fuel and contaminated groundwater out of the ground.
  • Jul. 8 – Aug. 17, 2026: Public comment on the plan, including a meeting in Washington Crossing (Upper Makefield Township).
  • Sep. 29, 2026: DEP sends a letter of deficiency and gives Sunoco 45 days to revise the plan.
  • Dec. 8, 2026: DEP community meeting at Sol Feinstone Elementary.

What DEP and Sunoco are doing now

DEP says treatment systems have been installed at 112 homes, with more scheduled. These point-of-entry filters are designed to remove contaminants from drinking water. DEP's sampling of Dyers Creek, Houghs Creek and the Delaware Canal found no petroleum compounds. Well testing results are still being posted almost every week.

The cleanup itself is where it stalls. In its September 29 letter, DEP said Sunoco's June plan is really a time-limited pilot test, and it doesn't explain how that method would actually get the groundwater clean enough to meet the state standard. DEP asked Sunoco to say which residential wells it will monitor during testing, define what "success" means, list the permits it needs, and lay out a reporting schedule. DEP agreed that the soil needs no further cleanup. It also "strongly recommends" starting the pilot test no later than May 31, 2027, and said there's no reason to wait for the water table to drop.

There's also a disagreement over permits. On its response site, Sunoco says it canceled a pilot test planned for fall 2026 after the Township told it local permits were required. Sunoco's position is that Act 2 cleanups don't need those permits, and it says it will consider testing in fall 2027. The Bucks County Herald has good coverage of the deficiency letter.

My take: the filtration systems are doing their job for now, but filters aren't a cleanup. Every season that passes without a working remedy is another season these families wait. A permit dispute shouldn't be what decides whether neighbors get clean groundwater. The meeting is where residents can push for a real schedule.

Why this matters for anyone on a private well

Pennsylvania doesn't regulate private wells. Testing them is up to the homeowner, and that's why I'm so firm about it. A lot of the older homes I sell in Upper Makefield and Washington Crossing are on wells, especially the old stone houses and farmhouses. A well isn't a problem. An untested well is.

My advice is the same whether you're near Mt. Eyre or miles away:

  • Test every year, with a state-accredited lab. The PA Department of Health recommends annual testing and extra testing after any nearby fuel spill (checklist).
  • Keep every result. A paper trail of clean tests is worth real money when you sell.
  • If you smell fuel, report it. Call Sunoco's hotline at 1-877-397-3383 and email DEP at RA-EPUMPIPELINE@pa.gov.

What I tell buyers and sellers near the leak

Buyers: Don't skip this area because of a headline. Do your homework. Make your offer contingent on a full well water test that includes petroleum compounds, not just the basic bacteria panel. Ask whether the house has a treatment system, who maintains it, and whether it transfers. Read DEP's posted test results for the street. Then talk to a real estate attorney and an environmental professional before your contingency period ends.

Sellers: Pennsylvania's seller disclosure law asks about water systems and hazardous substances, and in my experience being upfront always beats being found out. If you have test results or a treatment system, gather the paperwork before you list. What exactly you need to disclose is a question for your attorney, not your agent, so ask before your house goes on the market.

Why the December 8 meeting is worth your evening

This is the first in-person DEP meeting since the deficiency letter, and DEP experts will walk through site conditions, Sunoco's plan, the letter and next steps. If you own here, you'll learn more in two hours than from a year of secondhand rumors. If you're buying here, you'll know exactly what you're getting into.

DEP Community Meeting
Tuesday, December 8, 2026, starting at 6:00 PM
Sol Feinstone Elementary School, 1090 Eagle Road, Newtown
(DEP lists 6:00–8:00 PM; the Township's page lists 6:00–9:00 PM.)

FAQ

Where was the Washington Crossing pipeline leak?
In the Mt. Eyre Manor neighborhood of Upper Makefield Township, around Glenwood Drive and Walker Road, from Sunoco's Twin Oaks–Newark pipeline. Energy Transfer confirmed it on January 31, 2025.

Is the cleanup finished?
No. DEP found Sunoco's June 19, 2026 remedial action plan deficient on September 29, 2026, gave Sunoco 45 days to revise it, and recommended a pilot test start by May 31, 2027.

How many homes have water treatment systems?
DEP reports treatment systems at 112 homes, with more scheduled. Seven wells tested above drinking water standards for petroleum.

Should I test my well if I live in Upper Makefield?
Yes. Pennsylvania doesn't regulate private wells, and the state Health Department recommends annual testing at an accredited lab, plus extra testing after a nearby fuel spill.

When is the DEP community meeting?
Tuesday, December 8, 2026, starting at 6:00 PM at Sol Feinstone Elementary School, 1090 Eagle Road, Newtown.

Thinking about buying or selling a home on a well in Upper Makefield or Washington Crossing and want a straight answer? Call or text me at 215.431.0884 or email hj@heatherjackman.com.

Heather Jackman, REALTOR®, Coldwell Banker Hearthside. This post shares my experience and isn't legal or environmental advice. Talk to a real estate attorney or environmental professional about your situation.

Download File

Listings & Updates

704 Karens Court North Wales PA
By Heather Jackman • June 2, 2026
704 Karens Court North Wales PA
By Jackman • June 1, 2026
This New Bill Might Make A Difference
By Jackman • May 21, 2026
The Push-back against Wall Street Investors has begun
New Listing: 1682 Clydesdale Circle Yardley  PA 19067
By Heather Jackman • May 14, 2026
New Listing: 1682 Clydesdale Circle Yardley PA 19067
By Jackman • May 7, 2026
SOLD for $1.25 Million in FOUR DAYS!
104 West Ferry Road Yardley PA  19067 | $824,900
By Heather Jackman • May 7, 2026
104 West Ferry Road Yardley PA 19067 | $824,900
A two-story house with solar panels, a manicured lawn, a colorful flower bed, and a two-car garage under a blue sky.
By Jackman • April 7, 2026
118 Lesha Drive in Pennsybury School District
By Jackman • January 21, 2026
(Before You Spend, Read This)